Skip to content

Exposed by a Tie–An Experience with Lord Pentland

January 24, 2011

Lord John Pentland

Lord John Pentland

I had been in the Gurdjieff Work in San Francisco for a few years when I suddenly realized, in a very deep way, that I wished to be one of those few people who read at the end of the Sunday workday and Beelzebub’s Tales on Thursday evenings. I said nothing to anyone about this realization.

About two weeks later, Lord Pentland came to San Francisco and asked to see me in the panel room. At our meeting, he said that he would like me to read from Beelzebub’s Tales to the entire group the next evening, which was Thursday.

When I got home that evening, I thought about what I would wear at the reading. To understand my dilemma, it’s important to know that the readers for Thursday evenings, who happened to be men at that time, always wore a tie with either a suit or a sport coat and a nice pair of dress pants. Being somewhat of a rebel, or so I thought, and also hating to wear ties, I intentionally decided not to wear one, and arrived the next evening tieless, wearing my favorite sport coat and carrying my copy of Beelzebub’s Tales.

I spent about an hour in the library going carefully over the reading and then went down to the foyer and was standing there waiting for everyone to go in and sit down. Lord Pentland saw me, came quickly over to me, looked me up and down, and then, zeroing in on my neck and shaking his head sadly, said, “Oh no, that won’t do.” Of course, everyone stopped in their tracks, knowing something of import was about to happen. Lord Pentland told me to stay where I was. He then headed off to his room. The foyer was filled with silence.

A few minutes later he came back conspicuously carrying a very conservative looking tie. He then slowly and carefully in front of everyone lifted my shirt collar and proceeded to put the tie around my neck, tying the knot as though I were incapable of doing so, which I may well have been at that moment. I couldn’t believe what was happening to me. I felt like a foolish, helpless little child, on display for all the grownups to see. I saw myself! When he finished with the tie, he stepped back, looked at his handiwork. and said softly, “Now you’re ready.” Yes, I was. Thanks to this shock, an entirely new level of sincerity was alive inside me, though it was only later that I understood. Shortly after that evening, I was told by someone from the planning team that I would also be one of the regular readers on Sundays.

Without saying too much here, I will say that reading out loud to others in the context of the Gurdjieff Work helped me see and understand myself in ways that might not have been possible, or at least would have taken much longer, had I not had that wonderful and very challenging opportunity. What’s more, it brought me an entirely new understanding of what it means “to listen,” beginning with listening to my own deepest wishes and expanding outward to listening to the ever-changing tones and nuances of my voice in varying circumstances; the thoughts, emotions and sensations my own voice manifested and aroused in me; and how my voice influenced others. I know for a fact that Lord Pentland heard those wishes and that they were in harmony with the ways in which he believed I might be useful not just to myself but also to the Gurdjieff Work.

Copyright 2011 by Dennis Lewis

4 Comments leave one →
  1. Markus permalink
    May 24, 2011 1:34 pm

    This is really beautiful vignette. It is clear that he did this for YOU, not out of any shallow sense of decorum. Hard for me to make out anything that he was trying to say in the Exchanges Within book, but from accounts like this, and in books by Needleman, Paterson and Kherdian, the impressions I receive from recounted incidents like this leave me with the strong sense that Pentland embodied, lived, dramatized and exemplified what I take the Gurdjieff Work to be.

  2. June 6, 2014 2:29 pm

    Great episode, thanks. . . I remember Mrs. March describing how Gurdjieff would stop for a moment at the doorway of a French cathedral they were visiting, carefully straighten his tie, and only then walk in. It’s been a little work reminder ever since.


  1. Tweets that mention Exposed by a Tie–An Experience with Lord Pentland « Welcome to Dennis Lewis' Blog --

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: